
|
|
Comparison Tests
2000 Family Car Comparison Test
Fourth Place - 2000 Nissan Maxima
By Scott Mead
Date Posted 12-19-2000
Introduction
Styling, performance and handling. Three tenets Nissan
has held true for the Maxima for nearly 20 years.
The Maxima went under the plastic surgeon's knife
again for 2000, with a revised body style and a boost
in performance. Placing fourth overall, the Maxima
SE we tested grabbed the attention of our driving-enthusiast
editors, while our family-minded brethren saw it as
an overdone grocery-getter.
In nearly all of our tests, the Maxima fared well,
never dropping below sixth place (for exterior design)
in any category. The Maxima was also one vehicle for
which we had trouble prying the keys out of our editors'
hands.
Background and Our Test Vehicle When Nissan introduced the Maxima in 1981, the
car was an instant hit with striking good looks, sports-car-like
performance and fantastic handling to boot. Over the
years, the design was massaged to increase interior
room and drivability, but somewhere in the mix, Nissan
lost sight of the original vision, creating a truly
ugly Maxima in '95. When we see one of those third
generation vehicles today, we still aren't sure if
they are coming or going down the highway.
For 2000, the stylists at Nissan have returned to
their roots, bringing forth a Maxima that not only
performs like a sports car in the power and handling
departments, but also looks distinctly unlike anything
else on the road today.
Available in three trim levels (base GXE, the comfort
minded GLE and performance oriented SE), our SE test
vehicle came complete with a one-touch open and close
sunroof, 17-inch alloy wheels, an eight-way power
driver's seat, intermittent wipers and a cargo net
to keep the groceries in place.
Exterior Design
To say the Maxima is unique-looking would be a brash
understatement. Sporty, sleek and edgy. That's the
new Maxima. With its Ford Focus-like wheel well arches
and flowing lines, the Maxima is the most forward-thinking
model ever released from Nissan's La Jolla design
studios. Too bad the gaping front oval grille detracts
from the silky lines. With its gray undertones, we'd
rather see the grille body-colored to help with the
blending process.
Out back, the Maxima's new dual cat-eye tail lamps
add to the distinctive tone, but look more like an
afterthought and break up the smooth lines. Our editors
didn't agree with Nissan's decisions, placing the
Maxima in sixth place in the styling category, leaving
one editor to comment that he was waiting to see if
George Jetson might emerge from the driver's seat.
Interior Features,Controls, Materials and
Design If there's one aspect of the new Nissan Maxima
that did do well, it's the interior. With a classic
waterfall dash design, the Maxima's interior not only
looks clean and slightly futuristic, but it's user
friendly as well.
Standard cloth buckets hold driver and passenger in
place, but exhibit too much mid-back support and not
enough lower lumbar support to be of real comfort
on long drives. Driver's controls are well laid out,
with the exception of the remote mirror controls,
which forced us to lean forward out of our driving
position to manipulate the directional paddles. People
with long fingernails will appreciate the new climate
and stereo controls, which feature large buttons and
rotary dials, making for easy selections.
Rear occupants will find all the head- and legroom
they need, and the bench has a remarkable amount of
lumbar support. While the back seat is comfortable
for two adults, three will find the quarters a bit
cramped. A 12-volt power point, dual cup holders and
air vents complete the package.
Engine and Transmission For 2000, the Maxima SE's 3.0-liter SOHC V6 gets
a boost in horsepower to 222 ... yet it didn't feel
as fast, compared to last year's model. Nonetheless,
in our performance testing, the new Maxima made a
second-place finish in overall performance and handling
trials. Zero to 60 came in a very respectable 7.8
seconds (1.2-seconds slower than the '99 model), hammering
the quarter mile in 15.9 seconds at 89 mph (.4 seconds
and a whole mile-per-hour slower).
In typical Nissan fashion, the Maxima's engine is
buttery-smooth at idle and pulls hard throughout the
rpm band. The extra power comes from new intake and
exhaust manifolds, Nissan's Variable Induction System
and a new muffler that incorporates a valve that opens
at 2,000 rpm to reduce exhaust back pressure.
Our tester-equipped, electronically controlled four-speed
automatic transmission left us longing for the standard
five-speed manual variant. The auto tranny was slow
to shift and indecisive at times, often kicking down
from fourth to third, then snapping our necks as it
jumped into second for a rod-bending flash to redline.
Perhaps a little more calibration between the throttle
position sensor and transmission is in order.
Suspension, Ride and Handling When it comes to blending all aspects of driving
into one suspension system, Nissan does it right.
While the average Joe will think the suspension is
a little on the harsh side, we loved it. The SE transmits
just enough road feel into the cabin to accurately
communicate what is happening underfoot, yet filters
out the harshness that would make long trips unbearable.
As one of our editors remarked, 'The Maxima was designed
to handle first, coddle second.'
We couldn't agree more.
Normally, such a firm suspension would make mountain
driving a chore. Not so with the Nissan. Throw the
SE into a decreasing-radius turn and the suspension
holds, gracefully accepting throttle without the slightest
notion of stepping out. For the performance-minded
individual who wants to take the family around in
style, yet have fun when the opportunity presents
itself (without jolting passengers to death), the
Nissan is the logical choice.
Remember when you used to tie a string between two
soup cans to communicate with your buddy two feet
away? That same close communication is exactly how
the Maxima's steering interacts with the driver. If
you cannot feel exactly what is happening underfoot
of the Maxima, you need to have your circulation checked.
No matter what driving surfaces we traversed, we knew
exactly what the car was doing. While this isn't a
bad thing, many drivers like the numb feeling most
American cars have dialed into their steering response.
The Maxima, in our opinion, is the most communicative,
without being harsh on the driver.
Our only complaint: The standard issue 225/50VR17
tires are great in dry conditions, but when the weather
turns from bad to worse, the Bridgestones become unstable,
like an elephant walking over a floor of marbles.
Conclusion At our as-tested price of $26,468, the Maxima
is priced in the middle of the family sedan pack,
but delivers a lot more than the price reflects. Packed
full of features (like a one-touch up and down driver's
window, one-touch open and close sunroof, HomeLink
transmitter and auto on/off headlamps), the Maxima
SE is a great family car and a sports car wrapped
into one package. If Nissan could smooth the rough
edges from the styling, there's no telling how many
units they could sell.
Editors'Comments I'm in love with this homely Maxima. This car
spoke to me like no other I've driven in this test,
and communicates on a level only matched thus far
by the Passat. A true driver's car, the Maxima tore
down the mountainside, never even thinking about relinquishing
its grip on the road. Amazing performances were turned
in by steering, engine and brakes. Whoo-hoo! Whatta
ride! Christian Wardlaw.
Aighh! I'm turning into my parents! My mom bought
an '87 new, and then pawned it off to my dad so she
could buy a white '95 Maxima. They still own both.
And here I am saying that my favorite car of the test
was the Maxima. I'm even getting used to the new styling.
Before I know it, I'll be living in white-bread suburbia
and putting two kids through college. Brent
Romans
Stereo Evaluation - 2000 Nissan Maxima
|
|